Click Here!

Reviews for Thief of Hearts

By : ibshafer
  • From ANON - aesthir on November 23, 2008
    please continue! i know this story hasn't been updated in...forever, but i still hold out hope you'll pick it back up someday!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cristina on January 17, 2008
    This is such a lovely, flowing, beautifully written and magestically worded story. I absolutely adore your talents and the way you wrote this.
    Report Review

  • From on October 01, 2006
    I'm reviewing the second chapter, which I had not read. I still think it's a wonderful story, so at least that hasn't changed...lol. :) (:
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Josh on September 09, 2006
    Hope to see a new update from you. I have a few questions though. Is Ed in the past where he was sent when he turned his brother back to his original form. Two can you clear up the first chapter it was hard for me to understand who Noa is. What is going on with Ed and Noa.... E-mail me at JTB8834@aol.com
    Report Review

  • From ANON - dorwenna on September 04, 2006
    This story is...beautiful. I am a big fan of Ed/Winry, but you made me feel sympathy and understanding for Noa as well. I'm anxious to see what you do in future chapters.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - MissWoodford on September 03, 2006
    Yessss..... Where is this going? Will Noa bring his attention to Winry's alter, even if it means Edward drops her for a (figurative) chimera?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - wild seven on August 28, 2006
    A very good job, I liked it! ^^ So heartwrenching and sweet at the same time. :) (:
    Report Review

  • From sailtheplains on March 10, 2006
    Y'know, sometimes I come back and read stories that I really love. I put them on my favorites and I revisit. And everytime I come back to this story--I'm always really impressed by it. Even now, when I read it--I can feel the emotion from both of them. I just always enjoy it. This is one of my favorite stories.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Angel on March 08, 2006
    EEEK!! yay! I've been looking for a NoaxEd fanfic since I've seen the movie. And now I've finally found one! I just wish there were more. But still, this one will have to do. Thank you SOOOO Much!!! It was great.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sands on February 13, 2006
    Damn. I saw this on Mariam's Rec Reading and I am fucking glad I read it. This is awesome. This was so interesting. It totally captured my attention. I really, really, like this and I'll definetly be looking at your other works.
    Report Review

  • From sailtheplains on February 09, 2006
    Damn. I was really, really impressed with this. This just...yeah, you took the real psychological part of Ed. I really liked this.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nymphetamine Girl on January 12, 2006
    .... Wow. I'm... I'm seriously stunned here. This was... an amazing awesome story that deserves the highest praise. I was always fond of Noah. Didn't like her terribly, but I was fond of her. I'm a huge EdxWinry fan as well. This story was the best of both fandoms. Steering to EdxWinry and yet giving Noah some well deserved character insight. I always felt that if Ed and Noah ever had a relationship it would be something like this. A healing sorts... Ed's heart belonging to Winry and yet accepting Noah's love because it's what he wants from Winry... ya know? Excellent job. Five plus stars for sure and a gold medal. This was wonderful and I'm eternally jealous of your mad writing skillz. I wish I could write like you... Keep it up! I look forward to more stories from you!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ibshafer on January 12, 2006
    milky: You know when I was writing this, I was remembering a couple of your's and really hoping for the same tone. I'm so pleased you read it right away and thought it worked.

    As for the movie, I've JUST seen it, like, yesterday, and am not wanting to be critical yet, still so blissed at beautiful Edward and Alphonse, at Mustang *waiting*, hoping to see Edward and that sweet smile when he does, to see what is not good about it. I'm thinking it's just that knowing this is IT, that there will likely not be more (anime, anyway), makes me not want to bring displeasure to the experience. I suppose I'll get there, but until then, it's all still afterglow...

    Thanks for the review and we really should talk some time. I haven't been to the AFF forum yet - you?

    Report Review

  • From ANON - millky (fails at logging in :) on January 11, 2006
    Mmm, very very nice...you know, I couldn't STAND Noa, hated what I saw of the damn movie, and still this was just absolutely beautiful. Your writing made me see something that I thought was ugly, and it is beautiful :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ChibiGirl on January 11, 2006
    A very nicely written story... ^_^ I enjoyed it greatly.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!