rate_review Reviews

Damn. I was really, really impressed with this. This just...yeah, you took the real psychological part of Ed. I really liked this.

milky: You know when I was writing this, I was remembering a couple of your's and really hoping for the same tone. I'm so pleased you read it right away and thought it worked.

As for the movie, I've JUST seen it, like, yesterday, and am not wanting to be critical yet, still so blissed at beautiful Edward and Alphonse, at Mustang *waiting*, hoping to see Edward and that sweet smile when he does, to see what is not good about it. I'm thinking it's just that knowing this is IT, that there will likely not be more (anime, anyway), makes me not want to bring displeasure to the experience. I suppose I'll get there, but until then, it's all still afterglow...

Thanks for the review and we really should talk some time. I haven't been to the AFF forum yet - you?

.... Wow. I'm... I'm seriously stunned here. This was... an amazing awesome story that deserves the highest praise. I was always fond of Noah. Didn't like her terribly, but I was fond of her. I'm a huge EdxWinry fan as well. This story was the best of both fandoms. Steering to EdxWinry and yet giving Noah some well deserved character insight. I always felt that if Ed and Noah ever had a relationship it would be something like this. A healing sorts... Ed's heart belonging to Winry and yet accepting Noah's love because it's what he wants from Winry... ya know? Excellent job. Five plus stars for sure and a gold medal. This was wonderful and I'm eternally jealous of your mad writing skillz. I wish I could write like you... Keep it up! I look forward to more stories from you!!

Oh my gosh, would you look at that? I even signed in to review for ya ^_^

You know me and my RoyxEd obsession... but this... this was truly something else. I think it's absolutely beautiful deary.

I'm right there with ya on that obsession, hon. (Though as I told you the other day, I'm thinking that as long as *someone* gets Edward, I'm a happy camper...)

This just seemed a natural progression of the movie. Edward's 18 now. [shiver] Anime Ed is sort of uninterested in sex (no time! got a quest, y'know!), but asexual at 16 is one thing, at 18? Nothing doing...

Thanks for the review! Yer the best! (No, seriously. You're the best. :D)

~I~

Mmm, very very nice...you know, I couldn't STAND Noa, hated what I saw of the damn movie, and still this was just absolutely beautiful. Your writing made me see something that I thought was ugly, and it is beautiful :)

0.o
..........
damn...about time there was a noa/ed fic, and damn good job of it, too!

A very nicely written story... ^_^ I enjoyed it greatly.